The Danger of Moving the Goalposts During an Executive Search

by
Jeddalene Gito

A successful executive appointment begins with a clear understanding of what an organisation needs from its next leader. Defining the role, agreeing on key selection criteria and aligning expectations from the outset helps ensure the search attracts candidates with the right capabilities and experience.

However, as a search progresses, it is not uncommon for priorities to shift. New expectations emerge, stakeholders reconsider their preferences, or candidates prompt the organisation to rethink what it is looking for. While some flexibility is necessary, repeatedly changing the requirements can create challenges and undermine the effectiveness of the search.

When selection criteria change partway through the process, candidates who initially appeared well suited may no longer meet the revised expectations. This can lead to delays, additional costs and the risk of overlooking strong candidates who align with the original brief. It can also create confusion among stakeholders, particularly when decision-makers have different views about what the role requires.

There is also a risk that organisations become focused on finding an increasingly specific combination of skills and experience that may be difficult to find in a single candidate. In pursuing the ideal profile, they may overlook individuals who have the capability to succeed but bring a different professional background or perspective.

A more effective approach begins with thorough consultation before the search commences. Establishing clear priorities, distinguishing essential requirements from desirable attributes and ensuring stakeholder alignment creates a consistent framework for assessing candidates.

Of course, business needs can change, and a search should remain responsive to genuinely new information. The key is to make considered adjustments rather than continually redefining success.

At Morton Philips, we believe a well-defined search brief and strong communication throughout the process are essential to achieving successful executive appointments. By establishing clear expectations from the beginning, organisations can make more confident decisions and remain focused on finding the right leader for their future.

Back to news listings

Are you ready to take your next step?

Get in Touch